On Writing
As a writer one of the things I struggle with most is reading - how do you balance what you take in and what you put out? Where is interpreting, incorporating or hinting at someone else's words, thoughts or ideas plagiarism? A 19 year old student is facing charges that her novel is too similar to one of her favorite books - did she intentionally copy or was it all just a big mistake?
I don't know what is safest when you're writing - just not to read at all? I, myself, try not to read before I write during the day. If I'm planning on writing I will not open whatever I'm reading at the time...I feel like it's too risky. I'll read after I'm done writing for the day. But is that enough? Just because I sleep for 8 hours or so, does that mean that what I read the day before can no longer affect what I write?
According to www.dictionary.com, 'plagiarism' is defined as follows:
n 1: a piece of writing that has been copied from someone else and is presented as being your own work 2: the act of plagiarizing; taking someone's words or ideas as if they were your own [syn: plagiarization, plagiarisation, piracy]
Obviously what you write is influenced by what you read. You only ever broaden your horizons when you read, and in turn it makes you a better writer. But where is the line between inspiration and copying? This always makes me uncomfortable. I feel like my style is definitely influenced by what I read, but does that mean I copy? Do I imitate someone else's style? Is it then not completely my own? How do I know?
According to Plagiarism.org, in a study by the Center for Academic Integrity, 80% of college students admit to cheating at least once and 36% admit to copying written material. According to The State of Americans: This Generation and the Next (Free Press, July 1996)in 1969 58.3% of high school students allowed someone to use or copy their work. This percentage rose to 97.5% by 1989. The internet has made it that much easier to cheat...so is this girl just an example of another person taking advantage of the system? Or did she have the best of intentions.
I guess from my own perspective, I would never willingly copy anyone else's work. But how do I control the unintentional?
For more information check out:
http://www.plagiarism.org/index.html
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20060502/ap_en_ot/young_author
I don't know what is safest when you're writing - just not to read at all? I, myself, try not to read before I write during the day. If I'm planning on writing I will not open whatever I'm reading at the time...I feel like it's too risky. I'll read after I'm done writing for the day. But is that enough? Just because I sleep for 8 hours or so, does that mean that what I read the day before can no longer affect what I write?
According to www.dictionary.com, 'plagiarism' is defined as follows:
n 1: a piece of writing that has been copied from someone else and is presented as being your own work 2: the act of plagiarizing; taking someone's words or ideas as if they were your own [syn: plagiarization, plagiarisation, piracy]
Obviously what you write is influenced by what you read. You only ever broaden your horizons when you read, and in turn it makes you a better writer. But where is the line between inspiration and copying? This always makes me uncomfortable. I feel like my style is definitely influenced by what I read, but does that mean I copy? Do I imitate someone else's style? Is it then not completely my own? How do I know?
According to Plagiarism.org, in a study by the Center for Academic Integrity, 80% of college students admit to cheating at least once and 36% admit to copying written material. According to The State of Americans: This Generation and the Next (Free Press, July 1996)in 1969 58.3% of high school students allowed someone to use or copy their work. This percentage rose to 97.5% by 1989. The internet has made it that much easier to cheat...so is this girl just an example of another person taking advantage of the system? Or did she have the best of intentions.
I guess from my own perspective, I would never willingly copy anyone else's work. But how do I control the unintentional?
For more information check out:
http://www.plagiarism.org/index.html
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20060502/ap_en_ot/young_author
Labels: Writing



10 Comments:
At 2:53 PM,
Jeetan said…
LOL Ulla got to you too huh? I must admit this is fun. :p
At 2:56 PM,
Jeetan said…
Oh, and yes, it is a blatant example of plagiarism. There are so many passages that are clearly "similar" that it is hard to argue that it wasn't plagiarism.
Yet, as wrong as that is, is it any more wrong than the ridiculous patent laws created by the US (EU, WTO etc.) that create imbalances of creation? I am just posing the question, that's all.
At 3:12 PM,
Jeetan said…
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20060515/ap_on_go_su_co/scotus_ebay
This is a good non-sequitor that actually fits in well. So based on such a case, legally speaking, it is success that is a barometer of a courts injunction. Moreover, famous cases like Harry Potter, or the name of the group Nirvana, further highlight that success will "overcome" any patent/copyright issues.
So than why is it different with regards to plagiarism? Again, I am not advocating plagiarism itself, and certainly not advocating that girls plagiarism (and though I hate to debunk such a pretty girl, I do believe she plagiarized), but I am trying to highlight how patent laws are blatantly eschewed to begin with.
Don't even get me started on International patent laws, cause they are even worse. lol
At 8:18 AM,
Mira said…
Thanks for the comments! Yeah I'm addicted to this thing!!
I agree - laws regarding anything in this matter are very subjective. The line is blurry. I'm reading a lot these days, which means the writing has to slow down...but I'm always paranoid. Still how do you decide?
oh the link doesn't fully show so I couldn't see what you're talking about.
At 10:09 AM,
Jeetan said…
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20060515/
ap_on_go_su_co/scotus_ebay
I moved the part after the / to the next line, so you can read it.
Actually, if you had highlighted it and moved your cursor to the right, you can see the whole thing even in the original post.
At 2:07 PM,
Ulla said…
MUHAHAHAHAA! Resistance is futile; assimilation to Ulla's obsession with the internet is inevitable!
At 2:08 PM,
Ulla said…
thought provoking essay I feel a bit sorry for the girl........but she did plagiarizze.
At 5:27 AM,
Anonymous said…
Nice! Where you get this guestbook? I want the same script.. Awesome content. thankyou.
»
At 1:18 AM,
Anonymous said…
Hmm I love the idea behind this website, very unique.
»
At 6:43 AM,
Anonymous said…
Greets to the webmaster of this wonderful site! Keep up the good work. Thanks.
»
Post a Comment
<< Home